Skip to forex research
Simple Forex StrategiesRules / Quote / Account

Verify a Forex Strategy Record

Reconcile pair units, historical availability, complete calls, copied settings and cash accounting before accepting a forex performance claim.

Original source review: 8 October 2026. Numerical scenarios are fictional; no broker account or paid signal feed was tested. Expanded edition: 14 October 2026.

Guide revision and linked-source check: 10 October 2026

Identify the strategy, account and source version

A forex record can describe raw signals, a research implementation, a provider account or a copied subscriber. Name the exact object, instruments, period and cutoff before comparing percentages. A founder's personal return is not automatically a product result. A platform listing does not establish the validation method of every strategy available there.

Request original instructions, account evidence and an inspection route. Preserve the commercial offer and access tier relevant to the period; current terms cannot establish historical availability. A complete assessment needs definitions that could reveal a contradiction, not a generic trust score. CFTC's source supplies risk and due-diligence questions, but a missing record should remain an unresolved request rather than an unsupported allegation about a named operator.

Rebuild the information available at each decision

Map source event, release, receipt and revision. A current macro series may differ from the earlier vintage, while date-only evidence may be insufficient for an intraday claim. ALFRED helps distinguish vintage history without supplying every precise source-release clock. Retain that limitation instead of inventing a receipt instant that makes the backtest causal.

Record bid/ask versus midpoint basis, missing quotes, session and maintenance mapping. A favourable corrected price cannot become the entry a subscriber actually saw. Pair units and quote-to-account conversion need their own evidence. Preserve the declared research observation-window fill convention when a calculation is hypothetical, and keep actual fills under broker reports. A chronological file alone does not establish real-time availability or executable liquidity.

Reconcile complete instructions before the closed sample

Keep original IDs, amendments, cancellations, expired entries and open positions. A closed-trade win fraction needs its own denominator and gross/net definition. A repeated target update does not create another independent winning event. A service that stopped publishing should not disappear from a dated original population merely because its archive is harder to retrieve.

Take an invented twelve-message review: eight are entry instructions and four are commentary. Of the eight instructions, five are completed, two remain open and one expired without a fill. A five-outcome statistic does not describe twelve executed trades or eight completed instructions. Commentary cannot become an unfilled trade just to alter the denominator. These are classification fixtures, not a real provider sample or an estimated consumer-success rate.

Trace the copied or manual action separately

Join each instruction to the action actually accepted by the relevant account. For copying, save effective volume settings, instrument mapping, synchronization decisions and account identity. For manual signals, save receipt, decision and submission clocks. A source's trade price and quantity cannot simply be borrowed as the subscriber's result.

Order acknowledgement, partial fill and cancellation are distinct events. Cancelling an unfilled remainder does not remove entered exposure. A planned stop is not a broker execution report, and a chart touch cannot establish filled quantity. Costs and conversion must use the actual accounting convention or remain explicitly hypothetical. No paid-account test or private broker reconciliation was performed for this guide, so it publishes no invented subscriber return or successful replication claim.

Reproduce money, financing and selection history

Request quantities, price basis, fees, signed financing, conversion, marked exposure and external flows. A deposit cannot be counted as trading profit. A pip total, summed R and funded-account percentage are different metrics; define each denominator rather than choose the one closest to a supplier headline. Preserve open exposure at the cutoff and clarify whether the curve is closed balance or marked equity.

Inspect entry candidate history, fit scope and reserved evaluation. Entry identity must stay frozen on the authorised causal objective before one predeclared exit validates implementation. A revised exit tournament after inspecting outcomes is not fresh evidence. Software tests for units, clocks or conversions check correctness, not trader skill. This publication supplies no original forex population and therefore invents no confidence interval, Sharpe ratio, aggregate return or statistical significance.

Publish exactly which layer was checked

Separate source completeness, causal reconstruction, accounting reproducibility, independent evaluation and actual execution. Link findings to dated artifacts and retain unanswered requests. A supplier summary can be accurately attributed while remaining unreproduced. A later successful check should be linked to the earlier incomplete state rather than rewrite it as though verification had always existed.

The blank review record captures those distinctions. Work the commentary/instruction denominator example and unit fixtures outside empirical results. A deployment claim additionally needs current cloud revision and active subscriber route; local research files cannot establish customer delivery. This guide does not certify an operator, predict future results or substitute for account-specific professional advice. It helps a buyer recognise the original records required before a precise-looking forex headline deserves a stronger conclusion.

Review checkpoints

Evidence requests, not observed strategy results
ObjectPreserveDo not infer
PopulationCommentary, instructions and terminal statesEvery message is a completed trade
ReplicationSource and subscriber configuration separatelyPlatform inclusion proves exact copying
ConclusionUnits, accounting and independent evidenceA precise headline is an audited account return

Download blank research record (CSV)

Headers only. No trades, account outcomes or operating receipts are supplied.

Primary Sources

Forex Base-Unit Sizing Worksheet

Continue the Research

A conversion difference can be an accounting convention

An invented JPY-quoted case has negative 1,200 price change, 300 commission and negative 150 financing. Converting those at 0.0065, 0.0064 and 0.0066 account units per JPY gives negative 10.71 account units. Applying 0.0065 uniformly to the combined negative 1,650 JPY would give negative 10.725. The 0.015 difference concerns declared component conversion, not profitable FX alpha. An actual statement must provide its own amounts and conversion conventions. The new packet supplies neither a real broker event nor independently audited account performance.

The next record to acquire

Preserve the original product, source version, availability, eligible population and exact cost/quantity basis for the chosen question. An official mechanism reference does not authenticate a paid account, complete channel archive or current instrument entitlement. Failed variants and unresolved observations remain part of the study. The linked workbook contains authored examples, not extra independent evaluation data. A genuine instrument task must still complete its authorised factory and independently verified master; this educational addition neither promotes a model nor changes native exit ownership or the established research-fill convention.